Posted on

Is SIP in tax saving funds useful?

sip vs lumpsum

At CAGRfunds, January to March quarter is perhaps the busiest for us. No special reason why it should be so, but it is. Why? Because, many of our investors wake up to the need for tax saving investments just then. And then they end up investing a lumpsum amount in tax saving funds (ELSS).

What is wrong with that?

Well, nothing. Except that a lumpsum investment in any equity oriented fund forces us to lock a single price. What most investors miss are the problems they would face when they invest lumpsum instead of SIP.

Let us see an example of a SIP and a Lumpsum investment in an ELSS fund. We have two comparisons:

  1. SIP of 12,500 every month since 15th Dec 2008 until 15th July 2018, and
  2. Lumpsum of 1,50,000 every year on 15th December

Scenario 1: ABSL Tax Relief’96 (since 2008)

Scenario 2: Axis Long Term Equity Fund (since 2010)

Scenario 3: Franklin India Tax Shield (since 2006)

As we can see, an annual lumpsum investment in any of the above ELSS funds would have given significantly lower returns than SIP over the same period. This is because SIP enables the investor to invest every month at different prices. SIP thus averages out the cost of purchase. On the other hand, with a lumpsum investment, money gets locked in at one price and that can give lower returns if the pricing, unfortunately, is at a high level. This happened with a lot of our investors who had to compulsorily invest a lumpsum amount in ELSS in January 2018 since they were restricted by the last date of submitting tax proofs.

So if you have not yet planned your taxes and are still waiting for the last date to knock your doors, you need to think again. Feel free to post a comment if you have any questions!

Posted on

Should you go for the NPS (National Pension Scheme)?

National Pension Scheme

If a genie popped in front of me today and granted me three wishes, the child inside me would probably want to get an endless supply of money, a surreal supply of cake and to live forever to enjoy all of those things. But everything in life has an expiry date, including our wealth and us.

Therefore, the adult in me would wish for enough money to enable me to have a comfortable working life & a delightful retirement, a healthy & fit life and maybe a large cup of Cappuccino.

The fear of not having enough money to sustain ourselves post-retirement is real and that’s why the government launched the National Pension Scheme, so that we could garner enough to continue with our current lifestyle, even after our primary source of income is gone.

We, at CAGRfunds, have recently started enabling our clients to subscribe to NPS. Let’s try and understand what NPS can do for you!

National Pension Scheme or NPS, is a defined voluntary contribution pension system. It was initially started for Government Employees in 2004 but was later expanded to all citizens of India in 2009.

Investors can invest in both equity and debt which enables them to make good returns on equity while having the safe assurance of debt!

To understand better how and when to invest in NPS, let us have a look at Ramesh, Suresh and Mukesh and how their choices could affect them at the age of retirement.

Ramesh started investing in NPS at the age of 20 while Suresh and Mukesh started investing at the age of 30 and 40 respectively. Let us see how their investments will perform when they reach the age of 60 (Retirement Age).

Ramesh has done very well with his corpus standing at an astonishing 46 lakhs. At the same time, even though Suresh and Mukesh have invested 2.4 lakhs more than him, their investments are only 36 lakhs and 20 lakhs. This difference has arisen because of the power of compounding! You can read our article on the miracles of compounding here!

To help you out further, here is a small description of the types of NPS accounts:

Tier 1 (Investment Account)

It is an investment account wherein you can deposit money via SIP or Lumpsum. Investors can invest from the age of 18 years up until 65 years of age. Money once deposited in this account, can only be removed before maturity in a few circumstances. This often sends people away but we feel that its focused approach towards retirement prevents the customers from making mistakes during market volatility.

Note:

  1. You can withdraw up to 25% of your initial investment amount after three years of investing.
  2. Investors can withdraw 20% of corpus as lumpsum after ten years of investing.

There are two stages of investing. The first is the Accumulation Phase wherein you invest your money at regular intervals into NPS. The second is the Distribution Phase wherein the money comes back to you. Once you reach the age of 60, you have an option of withdrawing 60% of your corpus as lump-sum and you can buy a pension scheme (annuity) with the remaining 40%.

Note: It is compulsory to invest a minimum of 40% in annuity.

Government employees can mostly invest in corporate or government bonds. However, other investors can choose from various ‘Pension Fund Managers’ ranging from SBI and LIC to HDFC and ICICI. Investors can invest in two ways:

Active Choice

Investor gets to choose their investments. However, they have the following limits:

  1. Equity: Max 50%
  2. Bonds: No limit
  3. Alternative Funds: Max 5%

Auto Choice

In this option, investments are automatically adjusted based on the individual choice of plan. The exposure to equity will gradually reduce after the age of 35 in all three plans.

  1. Conservative Plan: Max 25% Equity
  2. Moderate Plan: Max 50% Equity
  3. Aggressive Plan: Max 75% Equity

Note: Investors can change their investment options twice a year and their PFMs once a year.

Tier 2 (Savings Account)

Tier 2 is a savings account. You can put and remove money as and when you wish as there is no exit load in this account. You can choose to invest in a Tier 2 account only if you have a Tier 1 account. It is possible to go back from a Tier 2 account to a Tier 1 account but once changed, you cannot change your account to Tier 2 again. In our view, one should only consider investing in Tier 1 account.

Tax Deductions

Investments

Investments in Tier 1 are tax exempt up to 1.5 lakhs every year under section 80C of the Income Tax Act. An additional 50,000 is also tax-exempt under section 80CCD (1b).

Investments in Tier 2 are not tax exempt and will be charged at slab rates (and hence, we feel that only Tier 1 is the relevant part in NPS).

Withdrawals

Withdrawals in Tier 1 have the following taxation:

  1. Premature withdrawal of up to 25% is tax exempt
  2. Withdrawal of 40% of investment at maturity is tax exempt. If you withdraw more than 40% (upper cap of 60%), then differential is chargeable at slab rate
  3. Returns earned on the part of corpus that is used to buy annuity (minimum 40%) are also tax-exempt
  4. Income from annuity will be charged at slab rate

Withdrawals from Tier 2 are not tax exempt.

In conclusion, as scary as the idea of growing old and having to let go of your lifestyle on your way to retirement seems, by investing in NPS now, you will save much more than enough to continue living your life the way you like it.

For further advise on investing in NPS, feel free to contact us at contact@cagrfunds.com or call / Whatsapp us on +91 9769356440.

Posted on

Everything about tax saving mutual funds

Benefits of ELSS Funds

Tax Saving Mutual Funds or ELSS (Equity Linked Savings Scheme) funds are a type of mutual funds which give you tax benefits under section 80C and also enable growth in your investment. Like all other equity mutual funds, they too invest in the equity market. So what makes them unique and desirable?

  • Potential of generating high returns (historically, the good funds have generated an average annual return of more than 15% )
  • Least lock-in period of 3 years compared to other tax-saving options
  • Deduction of ₹1.5 Lacs every year from taxable income, thus a saving of up to INR 45000 in tax
  • More equity exposure (linked with higher returns) than any other tax saving options
  • Available to HUFs also (Unlike individuals, HUFs have limited alternatives to save tax)

So, basically an individual or HUF (Hindu Undivided Family) can avail an exemption of ₹1.5 Lacs from their total taxable income in every financial year by investing in ELSS Mutual Funds under Sec 80C of Income Tax Act, 1961. In addition to this, a capital gain of ₹1 Lac is tax-free. Gains above ₹1 Lac are taxable @10% under Growth plans. Dividend plans will have a 10% tax levied from April, 2018.

How is ELSS better than other investment options (ULIP, FD, NPS, PPF, and NSC)?

Comparison of different tax saving optionsELSS will therefore be appealing to an investor who has a higher risk appetite as ELSS funds have the potential to outperform and generate better returns than FDs, NSCs, and PPF/EPF.

Final Thoughts:

There’s a widespread misconception that equity is too risky for older investors or for retirees and therefore they should not use ELSS. The truth being that every investor, who has a high risk appetite and wishes to invest in equity, has ELSS as a great investment option. It benefits your finances by saving on tax and generating better returns than traditional investment options.

The main issue that we, as Indians, face is inflation (6-7%). Fixed deposits and similar investments take a big hit because of inflation and the falling rupee rate. The returns are simply not rewarding and barely help to keep the value of the principal investment. For an investor saving for his children’s education, FD may not suffice as education inflation grows by 15% while for a retired person, prices for goods and services from healthcare grow by 20% due to inflation. Such long term investments maybe very underwhelming.

Of course, like all equity investments, the best way of investing in ELSS funds is through monthly SIPs throughout the year. Equity investment is a higher risk instrument over the short term. However over a span over 3 to 5 years, the market fluctuations are averaged out and the returns are usually healthy.

Investors can choose to invest lump sum too. Although, it is riskier than SIP as your returns can vary with the market highs and low. During a market high, it seems attractive to invest and during lows investors rush to stop investments. This is where they make lose on an opportunity. High markets fetch lower units and hence lower returns. Low markets fetch higher units and hence higher returns. Although, timing the market is never certain and it’s advisable to invest through SIPs as market highs and lows will produce a healthy average return in the long run.

Posted on

Budget 2018: What should investors be doing?

The much awaited Union Budget 2018 was presented and views as usual are multi-fold and diverse. Here is a short summary of the key questions that must be on your mind as an investor. Please feel free to post any further questions as comments or reach out to us on contact@cagrfunds.com. You can also Whatsapp us your queries on +91 9769356440.

Which are the sectors which are under Government focus?

The focus of the NDA Government is on strengthening the ground level infrastructure and thus the focus has truly been on the lower pyramid of the society. Most of the budgetary support has been rolled out to sectors which therefore impact the rural economy. Key sectors that are under focus are:

Agriculture & Rural – Focus on agriculture was an expected move this year.
  • MSPs to be 1.5 times the cost of input to the farmer. This should benefit all agri input companies (Seeds, Fertilizers, Pesticides)
  • Focus on improving access to maximum MSPs – Historically, farmers have not received the MSPs that they have deserved. While the Government claims to be committed to improving access, we need to wait and watch the success of the same.
  • Promotion of Organic farming – Will be useful for seed companies, not so good for fertilizers and pesticide companies. But given the small scale of organic farming in India, the impact is not expected to be material
  • Cold Storage – They are likely to be positively impacted if Operation Green is implemented well. A good part of potato production in India gets wasted and hence this is a welcome move
  • Overall, several initiatives have been rolled out for improving the rural livelihood. Actual benefits will depend on implementation
Health – Several initiatives have been rolled out for the Heathcare sectorHealthcare sector.
  • Flagship National Health Programme to cover 50cr people. Poor families to have better health insurance coverage
  • Focus on medical research
  • Use of generic drugs likely to increase

Should you then start investing in the thematic funds related to the above sectors?

Every year the budget rolls out some enhanced and some new policies for the key sectors. Short term sops lead to short term gains while structural reforms have a very long term play. From a broader picture perspective, sectors which are over exposed and dependant on Government policies should be avoided as any change in the Government itself or their priorities can have a very significant impact on particular sectors.

We therefore suggest that taking concentrated exposures in particular sectors should be avoided. In mutual funds, diversified exposures are always safer.

What is the tax implication on Equity?

Implication of Budget 2018 on Equity

What is grandfathering of returns?

If your investment in Mutual Funds and Equity is there for more than 1 year there would be a tax of 10% on the profit earned which was 0% as of now. For this they have considered Base Year as 31/01/2018 and profit calculation will be based on the higher of the two values – actual purchase price and the price on 31st January 2018.

For Example, consider that you have invested INR 100 on 1st September 2016 and you redeemed on 2nd April 2018.

Price on 2nd April 2018: INR 180

Price on 31st January 2018: INR 150

Long Term Capital Gains:  INR 180 – 150 (since this is higher than the actual purchase price of INR 100) = INR 30

Tax to be paid: 10% of INR 30.

Short Term Capital Gain remain unchanged at 15%.

With long term capital gains tax on equity being levied, are equity mutual funds still an attractive investment avenue?

Equity as an asset class is still attractive when we compare the returns with other asset classes. The benefit of compounding your money at a higher rate is immense when you are planning for your long term financial goal. Further, this taxation does take away some of your gains in the form of taxes, but even after the tax implication the post-tax returns are far more lucrative than other asset classes.

What does it mean for the debt mutual funds?

Debt funds still remain an attractive investment vehicle for people in the 20-30% tax bracket. In the present budget there has been no change in the tax structure for debt mutual funds so it remains an attractive investment avenue to gain from the benefit of indexation in the long run. Read more about how and when are Debt funds useful here.

What does it mean for you if you are a senior citizen?

The budget gives a big relief to senior citizen. Any interest a senior citizen earns either from fixed deposit or savings bank account is exempt to an extent of Rs. 50000.

So if you are a senior citizen and want to park an amount up to Rs. 700,000 for 1-5 years, then a fixed deposit now makes better financial sense for you.

What does it mean for you as a retail equity investor?

If you want to invest for the purpose of wealth creation with a time horizon of more than 5 years

For retail investors on a relative basis equity mutual funds still remain an attractive asset class. On a risk adjusted basis it will still outscore other asset classes. As a retail investor you will gain financial independence by saving more and maintaining your asset allocation as per your risk appetite. Also, it is recommended that choose “Growth” schemes as dividends are now taxable at 10%.

If you want to invest for 3 – 5 years (but more than 1 year) to generate better returns

For people who were using dividend option for such measures will have to re-look as dividends now will be taxed at 10%. However, a hybrid product such as a balanced fund may still outperform other possible asset classes for this objective. Therefore it is suggested that you take exposure in “Growth” options of balanced equity funds through the SIP or STP route. Lump sum (one time) investments in equity or equity mutual funds for such time frame should be avoided.

If you want to park your money for use between 1 – 3 years

Ultra – Short Term and Short Term debt funds where there is no change in taxation still remain an attractive investment avenue.

If you want to park your money for use within 1 year

Arbitrage funds as a category will become relatively less attractive as you will have to pay 10% taxes on dividends received. However, if you are in the 30% tax bracket, this is still a more lucrative option than other alternatives available (since Ultra Short term debt funds are also giving lower than average returns). On the debt side there is no change

If your existing holdings are in below types of funds, then what actions should you be taking?

Arbitrage funds – Stay invested till March 2018 since all changes take effect from April 2018.

  • If you are in 20 -30% tax bracket and withdrawal is planned within 1 year: Continue to stay invested in Arbitrage Funds even after March 2018
  • If you are in 20 – 30% tax bracket and withdrawal is planned after 1 year: Split exposure between Arbitrage Funds and Short Term Debt Funds
  • If you are in 10% tax bracket: Shift to Ultra Short Term and Short Term Debt Funds

Ultra Short Term Debt / Liquid Funds – Continue to stay invested. If funds are not required to be deployed in next 3 years, you can consider taking small exposures in equity on market corrections (if they happen over the next few weeks)

Dynamic Bond Funds – We are not recommending dynamic bond funds in the present scenario seeing the volatile debt markets to retail investors.

Short Term Funds – Short Term funds have had small hits because of the debt market volatility.

  • Investors should not look into the category for less than 1 year. For less than 1 year stick to ultra-short term funds
  • Some of you would have seen less returns in the short term funds in the last 3 months because of a sudden spike. We would like to emphasize that during our discussion with you we had suggested these funds for a horizon of more than 1 year. So please hold on the investments as the returns are likely to improve in the next 3-6 months

Duration Funds – We still hold our previous view of sticking to short term bond funds and accrual funds seeing the interest rate scenario.

Equity funds – As long as your time horizon is more than 5 years, stay invested. However, periodic look at the portfolio for re-allocation and re-balancing is inevitable. At CAGRfunds, we are committed to your wealth creation. While we are planning to start are annual re-allocation and re-balancing exercise after 15th February, 2018, do reach out to us if you want to discuss your portfolio prior to that.

Overall take: We feel that as retail investors we will benefit far more by focusing on the basics (which is our hand) which is consistent increase in our savings. Ensuring regular investments over a long period of time will help us reap the true benefit of compounding and create wealth over the long run. We therefore highly encourage starting / moving to the SIP mode of investment. While short term trading / speculation in direct stocks was never recommended for retail investors, it becomes all the more unattractive now. Also, the objective of investment at the first place is not to save tax. It is to build wealth. Equity mutual funds and a diversified portfolio continue to keep the objective intact and hence no major changes are required in the face of tax implication.

The only way to secure your future is to build it!

Disclaimer : This update is as per the information available as on 1st February 2018 from the budget document